What are the opening hours?

Monday 8:30am - 4:30pm Tuesday 8:30am - 4:30pm Wednesday 8:30am - 4:30pm Thursday 8:30am - 4:30pm Friday 8:30am - 4:30pm

Cayuga Mutual

Home
Canada
Cayuga, ON
Cayuga Mutual

Directions Website Contact the business

Cayuga Mutual Insurance Who We Are! As a result both the Oneida Farmers Mutual Insurance Company and the Grand River Mutual Fire Insurance Company were formed.

The concept of Cayuga Mutual began in 1875 when small groups of farmers decided to band together to protect one another from the financial ruin that would surely result in the case of a barn fire. These companies were run by members and operated in a true “neighbour helping neighbour” style. In 1970, both of these companies joined together to form the Cayuga Mutual Fire Insurance Company. Our company still operates on the same principles of neighbours helping neighbours. We are a part of the Ontario Mutual Insurance Association which is a network of 40 independent, purely mutual companies across Ontario. Each company is 100% independent, local and member driven. We do not have shareholders, simply policyholders who are all members and have a say in important issues in the company. Our company Board of Directors are all policyholders… elected by policyholders ensuring the policyholders interest always comes first. Come and see why Local is Better… the Mutual Way.

10/14/2026

Wishing the Norfolk Knights U14AA Team a great season!

Cayuga Mutual Insurance is dedicated to supporting healthy and positive activities for youth across Haldimand, Hamilton, Niagara, and Norfolk.

100% Canadian. Local Advisors. Small Town Service.

We're proud to be your local home team for insurance solutions.

🏒☕🏆🤝

10/09/2026

🦃 There’s a lot to be thankful for this Thanksgiving.

For us, that includes the members, families, farmers, businesses, and communities we’re fortunate to serve every day.

From all of us, Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours! We hope you enjoy a safe and relaxing long weekend with family and friends. 🍂

Our office will be closed Monday, October 12th for Thanksgiving.

🧡🇨🇦🍂🦃

10/07/2026

Different jerseys. Same team. 🏒⚾🏈

We had a little fun at the office last week with Jersey Day!

From hockey and baseball to football, there was no shortage of team pride around the office.

It's always nice to mix a little fun into the workday and enjoy some friendly competition!

Contact us for a competitive quote today!

10/01/2026

Caledonia Fair Time!

Your local home team for insurnace will be on site all weekend long with a ton of great giveaways and prize draws!

Come visit us at outside booth #14!

09/29/2026

Supporting Local!

Members of our team had a blast coming out to meet the last week.

We enjoyed meeting the coaches and players while we applied the Cayuga Mutual helmet stickers!

Thanks Bombers for a really fun time, and we're excited to support you this season!

🏒🇨🇦🤝

09/23/2026

Please help us welcome Anthony to the Cayuga Mutual Team!

Anthony brings a great balance of experience in both commercial and personal lines to the Agent team, and has hit the ground running serving his members and community.

Based in Stoney Creek, Anthony is a father of two and a certified soccer nut.

Fun Fact: Anthony was a soccer coach at Mohawk College, Redeemer College, and in the Canadian Soccer League!

Reach out to him today for a quote or policy review.

[email protected]

09/21/2026

The Cayuga Foodbank is a cause near and dear to our hearts.

In addition to dropping off monthly employee donations, we were a proud sponsor of their golf tournament held on Sunday September 13th at Cayuga Golf Club.

Our team was made of of players that spanned several departments (from left to right):

Ujjwal - Underwriting
Marey - Business Analyst
Steve C - Sales Manager
Myles - Chief Information Officer (CIO)

Sure, Myles missed the memo about wearing his light blue shirt and dark blue shorts, but we didn't miss many shots carding a respectable -9.

Great time and weather for another great cause.

See you next year Foodbank !

09/04/2026

We hope everyone enjoys their long weekend with family and friends.

Whether you're spending it at home, or away by the lake, take the time to unplug, recharge, and enjoy!

Please note our office will be closed on Monday September 7th, while our team does the same.

In the event of a Claims Emergency, please call 877-488-6642.

08/19/2026

We are proud to be a sponsor of the Dunnville Hospital & Healthcare Foundation golf tournament this Friday August 21st!

A great time for a great cause in the community.

⛳️

08/05/2026

The countdown is on!

1 week until we're at the Haldimand Federation of Agriculture 's 4th Annual Summer BBQ!

We are proud to be a Gold Sponsor of the event, and will have Jake and Jaden on site to connect with you and answer questions.

With some prizes and giveaways, please stop by our spot to say hello!

Riverside Exhibition Centre, Caledonia, ON

Doors open at 4:30pm

Dinner at 6:00pm

Come out and support a great cause!

Address

23 King Street
Cayuga, ON
N0A1E0

Opening Hours

Monday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Tuesday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Wednesday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Thursday	8:30am - 4:30pm
Friday	8:30am - 4:30pm

Website

https://www.cayugamutual.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cayuga Mutual posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cayuga Mutual:

Want your business to be the top-listed finance company in Cayuga?