19/08/2024
Case Scenario: Purchasing a $750,000 Home in Victoria
Home Details:
• Purchase Price: $750,000
• Loan Term: 30 years
• Loan to Value Ratio (LVR): 95%
Option 1: Basic (HGS) Variable
• Interest Rate: 5.99% Standard Variable
• Monthly Repayment: $4,491.81
• Total Repayment Over 30 Years: $1,617,451.58
• Upfront Fees: $0.00
• Ongoing Fees: $401.00 per month
• Repayment Frequency: Monthly, Weekly, Fortnightly
Pros:
• Flexible repayment options (monthly, weekly, fortnightly).
• No upfront fees.
Cons:
• Higher interest rate compared to other options.
• Monthly repayments are higher.
• Ongoing fees apply.
Option 2: FlexiDiscount Home Guarantee Scheme Loan
• Interest Rate: 6.14% Standard Variable
• Monthly Repayment: $3,837.50
• Total Repayment Over 30 Years: $1,657,809.00
• Upfront Fees: $0.00
• Ongoing Fees: $1,450.00 per month
• Repayment Frequency: Monthly
Pros:
• Lower monthly repayments compared to Option 1.
• No upfront fees.
Cons:
• Higher total repayment amount over 30 years.
• Higher ongoing fees compared to Option 1.
• Limited repayment frequency (monthly only).
Option 3: NHG Basic Variable
• Interest Rate: 6.19% Basic Variable
• Monthly Repayment: $4,588.65
• Total Repayment Over 30 Years: $1,652,264.97
• Upfront Fees: $0.00
• Ongoing Fees: $350.00 per month
• Repayment Frequency: Monthly, Weekly, Fortnightly
Pros:
• Flexible repayment options (monthly, weekly, fortnightly).
• Lower ongoing fees compared to Option 2.
• No upfront fees.
Cons:
• Highest interest rate of the three options.
• Highest monthly repayment amount.
Comparison Summary:
1. Monthly Repayment:
o Option 1: $4,491.81
o Option 2: $3,837.50
o Option 3: $4,588.65
2. Total Repayment Over 30 Years:
o Option 1: $1,617,451.58
o Option 2: $1,657,809.00
o Option 3: $1,652,264.97
3. Ongoing Fees:
o Option 1: $401.00 per month
o Option 2: $1,450.00 per month
o Option 3: $350.00 per month
4. Interest Rate:
o Option 1: 5.99%
o Option 2: 6.14%
o Option 3: 6.19%
"Recommendations:
• If you prioritise lower monthly repayments and can handle higher ongoing fees: Option 2 is the best choice, despite its higher total repayment and ongoing fees.
• If you prefer flexible repayment options with no ongoing fees: Option 1 provides flexibility but at a higher monthly repayment.
• If you want to balance between ongoing fees and repayment flexibility and can manage slightly higher repayments: Option 3 might be the optimal choice."