04/02/2019
The Law of Unintended Consequences
Well with the release of the Banking RC report yesterday and the talk of both Government and Opposition enacting all the recommendations, the Broking Industry is close to being wiped out.
True, we are paid commissions from the banks for placing a loan with them.
We are paid after the loan has settled. The banks do not pay us day to day, week by week, they only pay after the loan has settled.
We are not on the lenders payroll.
The commissions paid by the lenders are pretty well the same so there is no incentive for us to place borrowers with one lender over another based on the income we derive.
Soft commissions have been outlawed some years ago so things like holidays, wine and other incentives have long gone as an inducement from the lenders for us to put loans with them.
Currently, I am happy in general to accept the commissions paid by the lenders as full payment for my services.
For that, I meet with clients, in their home after hours most times.
I present to clients options beyond the big four banks and lenders that have shop fronts for you to walk into.
Thus creating competition from the lenders to try to win your business.
If a client now has to pay the broker for this service, at a set fee, will the client pay?
A recent survey of over 2,000 prospective borrowers showed that 90% of them would not pay and would go directly to a bank.
Imagine a first home owner who has struggled to save a deposit being hit with a bill of $2,000 to pay a broker. That is a big pill to swallow no matter how good the service is that I offer.
Two things come out of that.
1/ The banks with the shop fronts win, leaving other lenders floundering for business.
2/ The possibility of a tainted credit report for the borrowers if they have made the poor choice of applying directly to a bank and then being declined.
At least with a broker, we are able to place you with the most appropriate lender for your circumstance.
Yes, I get declines, but often not from misplacement but from other issues not always disclosed to me.
So the outcome of the implementation of the recommendations from the Banking RC pertaining to brokers has the potential to impact a lot of people on both sides of the deal.
Over 60% of loans are currently lodged with lenders through brokers.
6,000 brokers nationally will be impacted by the actions that are forthcoming.
Support staff to those brokers will also be impacted.
Close to 10,000 peoples incomes stand to be effected by the recommendations
60% of the borrowing public stand to lose the ability to have a choice beyond the major banks.
Lucky I have my Heavy Rigid Licence so can go drive trucks for a living!!!!