My Insurance of Murray & Paducah

Call Website

My Insurance of Murray & Paducah My Home. My Community. My Insurance. An independent insurance agency helping you find the right coverage for your needs.

Meet Donna MarquardtIf you've spent much time around Murray, there's a good chance you've crossed paths with Donna.Wheth...
08/06/2026

Meet Donna Marquardt

If you've spent much time around Murray, there's a good chance you've crossed paths with Donna.

Whether she's volunteering with the Murray-Calloway County Chamber of Commerce, helping at the Annual Watch Pickleball Tournament, or out on the pickleball courts herself, Donna enjoys being part of the community she calls home.

She's also been helping clients at our Murray office since 2007.

Donna works with families on everything from auto and home insurance to life, health, and Medicare coverage. She has a gift for explaining complicated options in a way that's easy to understand, helping clients find coverage that fits both their needs and their budget. With nearly two decades of experience and her CISR Elite designation, she's someone her clients know they can count on.

When she's not at the office, you'll usually find her spending time with her husband, Butch, their children, and their grandchildren.

The name on the building may have changed, but Donna is still the same trusted advisor so many families have relied on through the years.

We're proud to have Donna as part of My Insurance.

My Insurance may be growing, but we’re still the same local agency.We live and work in the communities we serve. Our cli...
08/05/2026

My Insurance may be growing, but we’re still the same local agency.

We live and work in the communities we serve. Our clients are our neighbors, friends, and local businesses. That means the way we serve you matters to us.

As we move forward under the My Insurance name, we want to be clear about what you can expect from us:

We start by listening.
We find the right fit.
We stay with you.

We’ll take the time to understand what matters to you, help you find coverage that fits your needs, and continue to be here as life changes.

That’s our promise to you.

My Home. My Community. My Insurance.

Murray the Penguin is settling into his new look!He may have a new umbrella, but he’s still the same friendly face you k...
08/04/2026

Murray the Penguin is settling into his new look!

He may have a new umbrella, but he’s still the same friendly face you know. You’ll continue seeing him around My Insurance as we serve families and businesses throughout Murray, Paducah, and the surrounding communities.

New name. Same Murray. Same local team.

Today marks an exciting new chapter for our agency. The Murray Insurance Agency and Insurance of Paducah are now My Insu...
08/03/2026

Today marks an exciting new chapter for our agency. The Murray Insurance Agency and Insurance of Paducah are now My Insurance.

While our name has changed, the things that matter most haven't. You'll still find the same local offices. The same familiar faces. The same commitment to helping you protect what matters most.

Our new name reflects where we're headed. As we continue to grow and serve more communities across western Kentucky, we wanted a brand that brings everything together while staying true to who we've always been. At My Insurance, we believe insurance is personal. Every family, every business, every farm, and every stage of life is different. That's why we start by listening, work to find the right coverage for your needs, and stay with you as life changes.

To our clients, friends, and communities: thank you for trusting us over the years. We're grateful for the relationships we've built, and we're excited to continue serving you under our new name.

Welcome to My Insurance.

My Home. My Community. My Insurance.

Murray the Penguin has one job...Hold onto that rope until Monday.We can't wait to share what we've been working on. See...
08/01/2026

Murray the Penguin has one job...

Hold onto that rope until Monday.

We can't wait to share what we've been working on. See you then!

For more than 80 years, we've been honored to serve the families, businesses, and communities of western Kentucky.As we'...
07/30/2026

For more than 80 years, we've been honored to serve the families, businesses, and communities of western Kentucky.

As we've grown, we've been preparing for what's next. On Monday, we'll begin sharing a fresh new look that reflects who we are today while continuing the same commitment to the people and communities we serve.

We can't wait to share this next chapter with you!

There’s something special about an open road and nowhere in particular to be. Whether it’s a weekend getaway, a scenic d...
07/23/2026

There’s something special about an open road and nowhere in particular to be. Whether it’s a weekend getaway, a scenic drive through Western Kentucky, or just an evening ride with the top down, those moments are meant to be enjoyed.

Wherever the road takes you, we'll help protect what matters most.

If it's been a while since you've reviewed your auto insurance, we'd be happy to help you make sure your coverage still fits your life.

Summer has a way of filling up the calendar. Between vacations, weekends at the lake, and everything else going on, we j...
07/21/2026

Summer has a way of filling up the calendar. Between vacations, weekends at the lake, and everything else going on, we just wanted to take a minute to wish everyone a fun and safe season.

If anything has changed over the last few months, like a new vehicle, a home project, or even a new toy for the summer, it might be worth taking a quick look at your insurance. If you have questions, we're always happy to help.

We hope you have a great summer, and if you need us, just give us a call or stop by. We'd love to see you.

Our offices will be closed on Friday, July 3rd. Wishing you a safe, happy, and memory-filled Independence Day!Whether yo...
07/03/2026

Our offices will be closed on Friday, July 3rd. Wishing you a safe, happy, and memory-filled Independence Day!

Whether you're spending the day at the lake, around the grill, watching fireworks, or just enjoying time with family and friends, we hope it's a weekend full of moments worth celebrating.

From all of us at, and Murray the Penguin, Happy Fourth of July! ❤️🤍💙

Murray has a few thoughts before the holiday weekend... 🐧🇺🇸Sure, penguins know a thing or two about staying cool, but th...
07/01/2026

Murray has a few thoughts before the holiday weekend... 🐧🇺🇸

Sure, penguins know a thing or two about staying cool, but they've also learned that a little preparation goes a long way.

Whether you're grilling in the backyard, spending the day at the lake, or watching fireworks with family and friends, a few simple precautions can help make the weekend memorable for all the right reasons.

Take a minute to check out Murray's Fourth of July Survival Guide, and have a safe, fun, and happy holiday weekend!

Address

Paducah, KY

Opening Hours

Monday 8:30am - 4pm
Tuesday 8:30am - 4pm
Wednesday 8:30am - 4pm
Thursday 8:30am - 4pm
Friday 8:30am - 4pm

Telephone

+12704426137

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Insurance of Murray & Paducah posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share